Understanding Nonprofit Culture
And How It Can Determine Your Consulting Effectiveness
I think it's a fair truism that independent consultants are hired by nonprofits to change something. I've been hired to change really big things, like launching new program areas, and relatively small things, like helping a nonprofit develop better budget planning systems. Even when it seems like you've been engaged to execute on something, such as writing digital fundraising appeals or grant proposals, it's still the case that you were hired because something wasn't working, and your client needed you to help change it.
Change is hard, though. [That's why we all need therapists.] It's particularly hard for nonprofits to change because of the hold of culture. Yet organizational culture is often one of the bedrocks of success. How to reconcile the opposing forces of culture is the point of this article.
Understanding the nuances of nonprofit culture will help you in delivering more effective services. While many experts have written extensively about company culture, this article is trained on nonprofits (NPO). These observations will help you navigate the cultural landscape of your nonprofit clients and avoid common pitfalls that can undermine your consulting effectiveness.
Thanks for reading! This post is public so feel free to share it.
Past Or Future: Helping Clients Move Beyond Historical Decisions
Nonprofit culture often emerges from the codification of successful past decisions. When leaders make the same choices again and again that benefit the organization, these approaches become "the right way of doing things." Over time, they evolve into cultural pillars that become unquestioned and even unnoticeable.
David Foster Wallace. Visual created using DALL·E by OpenAI.
The problem that I have frequently encountered with nonprofit clients is their cultures remain anchored in past circumstances despite changed conditions. For example, one NPO maintained a cultural prohibition against spending money on non-essentials. Born during early financial struggles, this cultural artifact served the NPO well over the years and led to financial security, and eventually to accumulating reserves many times its annual budget.
But what was a key to success has now turned into a blocker. Today, its culture prevents this NPO from making sensible investments like brand equity polling that would cost less than 1% of their annual budget but deliver significant benefits.
When consulting with nonprofits, identify where cultural norms based on historical circumstances may limit current effectiveness. Whatever your area of expertise, position yourself as a guide who can help organizations honor their history while adapting to present realities.
Promotion Or Prohibition
Many organizational cultures are focused on promoting certain behaviors. Airport booksellers probably make the majority of their sales from books about the Amazon way or what Googlers are like. The Netflix culture deck still has a cult following.
These can be fun reads, because many cultural values appear to promote specific behaviors while actually prohibiting others. And in this dramatic tension, an airport bestseller is born. (For an entertaining read, I highly recommend The Fund.)
As a consultant, recognizing these hidden prohibitions is crucial to implementing effective change.
Visual created using DALL·E by OpenAI to illustrate a concept from Sam Landenwitsch.
Consider an NPO I learned about that emphasized solidarity and unifying behind decisions. The behavior that was extolled in the NPO's culture was loyalty. While presented as unity in purpose, this cultural value functionally prohibited questioning leadership decisions. Staff implemented directives without critical evaluation, resulting in subpar strategic outcomes.
When working with nonprofit clients, look beyond stated cultural values to identify unstated prohibitions. Help your clients understand how promoting certain behaviors may inadvertently stifle others essential for organizational health.
Culture Is Not An Operating System
Many nonprofits confuse standardized procedures and specialized vocabulary with organizational culture. As a consultant, helping clients distinguish between operational systems and true culture creates clarity and may unlock a greater willingness to change.
Key Dynamics to Consider:
Resistance to Procedural Change: When organizations believe their operational systems are cultural artifacts, they become unnecessarily resistant to process improvements that don't actually threaten their identity.
Vocabulary as Barrier: Specialized internal language can create efficiency but may also serve as an exclusionary mechanism that prevents fresh perspectives from being heard.
Cultural Diagnosis: Help clients identify which elements are truly cultural (values, beliefs, assumptions) versus which are simply operational choices that can be modified without threatening organizational identity.
Here is an example of how this can play out. Imagine a community health nonprofit that prides itself on its "collaborative culture." Upon closer examination, what they call "collaboration" is actually just a complex approval process requiring five different departments to sign off on any new initiative. When you suggest streamlining this process, leadership resists, claiming it would damage their collaborative culture.
Overall, you'll want to position your consulting services as helping nonprofits develop both effective operating procedures and authentic cultural values that support their mission. In the hypothetical from the previous paragraph, you could help the community health nonprofit recognize that true collaboration means meaningful engagement and shared decision-making, not procedural checkboxes. By reframing the conversation around enhancing their collaborative values rather than eliminating their processes, the nonprofit could implement a more efficient approval system while strengthening authentic collaboration.
Visual created using DALL·E by OpenAI to illustrate a concept from Sam Landenwitsch.
Cultural Power Dynamics
The last point flows into this one: nonprofit organizational cultures often develop distinct patterns around how power is distributed and decisions are made. These cultural norms significantly influence how change happens (or doesn’t) within the organization.
Many nonprofits develop cultural traditions that create multiple centers of influence—formal leadership, program staff, long-tenured employees, and community representatives—each with culturally-sanctioned authority to shape decisions. This distributed cultural power can create environments where consensus-building is highly valued, but it can also lead to cultural resistance when recommendations challenge established power dynamics.
Imagine an education nonprofit with a strong cultural tradition of program autonomy where each department operates as a "mini-organization" with its own cultural norms. While leadership formally approves strategic plans, implementation stalls because the organizational culture values departmental independence over centralized direction. Your recommendations might fail not because of formal rejection but because they conflict with deeply-held cultural beliefs about how the organization should function.
How to head this off? Take time to understand the cultural narratives around power and decision-making. Identify which voices carry cultural authority beyond their formal roles. Position your recommendations to work within the organization's cultural framework for change rather than against it, acknowledging that sustainable change must align with—or thoughtfully evolve—existing cultural values around how decisions should be made.
When Work Is Personal
The emotional connection to mission creates a consulting environment unlike corporate settings. For many nonprofit staff, their work represents deeply held personal values and identity beyond just professional obligations.
Media coverage of my first campaign event
This emotional investment creates both opportunities and also challenges for consultants. Staff passion drives commitment and resilience but can also make organizational critique feel like personal criticism. Resistance to change often stems not from logical objections but from emotional attachment to existing approaches that staff associate with the mission.
You've probably experienced some version of this hypothetical. You're working with a human rights organization and encountering strong resistance to streamlining certain programs despite clear evidence of ineffectiveness. The resistance stems not from data disagreement but from staff members' emotional connection to program participants and fear that changes symbolize diminished commitment to those served.
When consulting in this environment, acknowledge the emotional dimensions of your recommendations. Frame changes in terms of enhanced mission impact rather than efficiency alone. Create opportunities for staff to express concerns about how changes might affect their connection to the work. Position yourself as someone who shares their commitment to the mission while offering fresh perspectives on achieving it.
Culture Aligns With Mission
The most vibrant nonprofit cultures seamlessly connect with organizational mission. Staff embrace values and behaviors when they clearly see how these elements advance their social impact goals.
For consultants across specialties, this alignment (or misalignment) profoundly affects your ability to implement recommendations. Let's say you're supporting a youth development organization whose mission centers on empowering young people through leadership development and self-directed learning. Their stated values emphasize youth voice and autonomy. Yet their internal culture had evolved to prioritize control, risk avoidance, and adult decision-making.
Imagine you're their communications consultant, and you are tasked with creating messaging that would attract more program participants and donors. You might discover that your carefully crafted language about "youth empowerment" rings hollow because it contradicts the organization's actual practices. Staff would be uncomfortable promoting values they weren't experiencing themselves, and young people in their programs would sense the disconnect.
Your communications recommendations—technically sound and based on market research— would gain little traction because they conflicted with the organization's lived culture. The misalignment between mission and culture would create resistance that no amount of strategic messaging could overcome.
No matter your area of focus, when you encounter resistance to your recommendations, consider whether you're facing a culture-mission misalignment rather than simple resistance to change. Your expertise may be unimpeachable, but if your solutions require behaviors that contradict the organization's cultural norms, implementation will remain an uphill battle. If that's happening, help your clients identify where cultural elements have become disconnected from mission. When culture and mission align, implementation of your recommendations becomes more natural and sustainable.
Thanks for reading The Chorus Consultant Community! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.
Conclusion
By recognizing the unique cultural dynamics that shape nonprofit organizations, you position yourself to deliver more effective, contextually appropriate solutions that resonate with your clients' realities.
The cultural elements we've explored create an organizational landscape distinctly different from the corporate world. As a consultant in this space, your ability to navigate these nuances will distinguish your services and deepen your client relationships.
Nonprofit culture isn't just a barrier to overcome but a rich context that informs how change happens within these mission-driven organizations. Your challenge is to honor cultural realities while gently guiding clients toward new possibilities.